Unlock the Editor’s Digest without cost

Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly publication.

British auto lenders may resist £13bn in compensation payouts after the UK monetary watchdog set out the size of a probe into historic fee agreements that allegedly led to shoppers overpaying in offers courting again to 2007.

The Monetary Conduct Authority on Wednesday clarified the timeline of an investigation it launched earlier this month into historic interest-linked offers supplied by motor finance corporations. The so-called discretionary commissions gave automotive finance brokers and sellers an incentive to boost rates of interest on buyer offers and had been banned by the FCA in 2021.

The FCA’s clarification despatched shares in Lloyds Banking Group down greater than 2 per cent whereas shares in specialist lender Shut Brothers fell practically 3 per cent.

Analysts stated Lloyds — which owns Black Horse, the UK’s largest automotive finance lender — is especially uncovered to an inflow of compensation claims, with Jefferies estimating the lender might be hit with a complete invoice of £1.8bn.

Different lenders together with Barclays and Santander had been additionally prone to be affected, analysts stated, whereas NatWest was unlikely to really feel a cloth impression due to its low publicity to the sector.

The watchdog stated its probe would come with offers made between 2007 — when the Monetary Ombudsman Service first began overseeing client credit score — and 2021, main specialists to extend estimates of the whole redress value for lenders.

Consequently, analysts at Jefferies anticipate the whole invoice for the business may mount as much as about £13bn, up from earlier estimates of about £4bn, based mostly on estimates that customers overpaid a complete of practically £7bn within the interval.

“These motor finance corporations had been traditionally providing discretionary fee whereby they set a fee and gave the dealer a chance to find out which fee is given to the client,” stated Kate Robinson, principal at regulatory consultancy Avyse Companions. “When you’re a buyer, you would have been charged the next fee for the lending in an effort to enhance the dealer’s fee.”

Robinson and different specialists have likened the probe to the fee safety insurance coverage scandal, which dates again to the Nineties when banks mis-sold insurance coverage to hundreds of thousands of shoppers, main banks to later pay billions of kilos value of fines and buyer compensation claims.

Simon Evans, head of the Client Redress Affiliation, a commerce physique for claims administration corporations, stated the FCA’s announcement was “excellent news” for shoppers.

“All of the shoppers which were affected deserve the identical likelihood to be compensated and redressed whether or not they had been affected in 2007, 2009 or 2013,” Evans stated.

Black Horse stated: “We’re at present reviewing the FOS choice and can work collaboratively with the FCA on their upcoming evaluation.”

Shut Brothers declined to remark.

Bonus season — are you headed for a payout or a doughnut?

For the third yr in a row, the Monetary Instances is asking readers to confidentially share their 2024 bonus expectations, and whether or not you plan to take a position, save or spend the money. Inform us through a brief survey